I would think that if Isildur did destroy the ring how will they get out of Mordor!The Fellowship will never meet, The Quest for Erebor will be a fail, Smeagol will be a normal hobbit and die!Aragorn would be king and live in Gondor or Arnor(from birth) and not be a ranger! Gandalf,Radagast and Saruman might have never come to Middle earth!Denethor wouldn't be a FIREBALL!!!!
Oh my... This is just too great for words. The faces, the poses and not to mention the throwing scene, hilarious. I always did wonder why things never played out like this, I mean who would suspect anything if Elrond said that Isildur "accidentally" fell in. Well done!
OMG! You have no idea how happy I am that someone FINALLY did a comic like this because every single time I watch this scene, I think "WTF, Elrond just throw that guy into the lava!" Glad to see that I'm obviously not the only one to think that. Nicely done, btw!
I kind of wonder what shape Elrond was in at the time. In my mind's version of events he exhausted himself trying and failing to heal Gil-galad and was then stuck watching as Isildur walked away with the Ring. Possibly he wasn't making a huge amount of sense to Isildur, making him easy for Isildur to ignore. Once Isildur was back among his own people he would have been impossible to get at without igniting another war.
I watched this movie for the 1,000th time a few days ago and I had a conversation about this while watching the scene xD Elrond should have done that, and nobody would have gotten hurt...! Awesome pic, by the way xD